News
news Russians drive over North Pole to Canada
news Concentrated Fukushima radioactive plume staying on narrow path toward U.S.
news How to Use Chinese Condiments
news Google’s Plan To Take Over The World
news 'Dead' man comes back to life at his funeral
news Visualizing The Silver Squeeze
news Geothermal Energy
news N.A Poe, Adam Kokesh and Others Arrested at Smokedown Prohibition Cannabis Protest in Philadelphia
news FEMA Plans Clear-Cutting 85,000 Berkeley and Oakland Trees
news Media Now Openly Admitting The Government Controls The News
news Woman who survived flesh-eating infection, receives bionic hands
news Billionaires Now Own American Politics
news Air Force Chemtrail Whistleblower Exposes Geoengineering
news Yahoo Japan suspects 22 million user IDs leaked: Kyodo
news Ruins of Lost City May Lurk Deep in Honduras Rain Forest
news Dark, massive asteroid to fly by Earth on May 31
news Greek addicts turn to deadly new drug 'sisa'
news How to Share Difficult Information with Friends
news CARA (newest advance in Facial Recognition Tech) Sees ALL, Knows All, In Real time
news How Trolls Ruin Your Ability to Reason

Username:
Password: or Register
 
Thread Rating:
  • 3 Votes - 5 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Adama VS Kirk, whose the better leader?
The Evil AC
I am not a number!!!
User ID: 666
04-18-2012 04:20 AM

 



Post: #1
Adama VS Kirk, whose the better leader?
New BSG, Classic Star Trek...
Which of the two would you prefer to lead a starship or fleet or even humanity in a given crisis?
Quote this message in a reply
Zero Point
Well I thought it was funny.
User ID: 86957
04-18-2012 04:21 AM

Posts: 10,052



Post: #2
RE: Adama VS Kirk, whose the better leader?
Kirk used to punch shit out of aliens.
He's got my vote.

CENSORED (by popular demand).
Quote this message in a reply
LoP Guest
lop guest
User ID: 58069
04-18-2012 04:21 AM

 



Post: #3
RE: Adama VS Kirk, whose the better leader?
Quote this message in a reply
Nyhee
.
User ID: 89080
04-18-2012 04:48 AM

Posts: 3,579



Post: #4
RE: Adama VS Kirk, whose the better leader?
Adama was stuffy, he gave in to his crew and the colonists when they wanted to settle on the earth like planet before reaching their destination.

Kirk was hated, but he took control. And it saved people, over and over again. He cared deeply about his crew, and they him.

His strategies were off the cuff, but they worked because his heart was in it.

Adama lost his heart when his son died, and never fully recovered, or allowed himself to recover.

I'll pick Kirk any day, over Adama, because Kirk will put his heart on the line, Adama won't.
Quote this message in a reply
Pope Barbie Imaculata
Praise "Bob"
User ID: 82216
04-18-2012 05:02 AM

Posts: 9,024



Post: #5
RE: Adama VS Kirk, whose the better leader?
Kirk. Because he would do the right thing even if it meant going against orders.

Grand High Pope of the Discordian Church of the blessed Dobbs head.
[Image: 5196b1f0c6991.jpg]
Quote this message in a reply
The Evil AC
I am not a number!!!
User ID: 666
04-18-2012 05:06 AM

 



Post: #6
RE: Adama VS Kirk, whose the better leader?
barbsat  Wrote:
Kirk. Because he would do the right thing even if it meant going against orders.

And Adama didn't defy Admiral Cain?
Quote this message in a reply
Nyhee
.
User ID: 89080
04-18-2012 05:08 AM

Posts: 3,579



Post: #7
RE: Adama VS Kirk, whose the better leader?
The Evil AC  Wrote:
barbsat  Wrote:
Kirk. Because he would do the right thing even if it meant going against orders.

And Adama didn't defy Admiral Cain?

He had her killed.

What a lousy guy. He could have kidnapped her, took over, or whatever, but no, he had her killed.
Quote this message in a reply
The Evil AC
I am not a number!!!
User ID: 666
04-18-2012 05:09 AM

 



Post: #8
RE: Adama VS Kirk, whose the better leader?
Nyhee  Wrote:
The Evil AC  Wrote:
barbsat  Wrote:
Kirk. Because he would do the right thing even if it meant going against orders.

And Adama didn't defy Admiral Cain?

He had her killed.

What a lousy guy. He could have kidnapped her, took over, or whatever, but no, he had her killed.

He risked the Galactica to get back two crew members.
Quote this message in a reply
Nyhee
.
User ID: 89080
04-18-2012 05:17 AM

Posts: 3,579



Post: #9
RE: Adama VS Kirk, whose the better leader?
The Evil AC  Wrote:
Nyhee  Wrote:
The Evil AC  Wrote:
And Adama didn't defy Admiral Cain?

He had her killed.

What a lousy guy. He could have kidnapped her, took over, or whatever, but no, he had her killed.

He risked the Galactica to get back two crew members.

Kirk has done the same. But what risk did he take in killing her? In fact, he risked making her a martyr which is even more of a mistake in his strategy if you think about it. just my opinion...
Quote this message in a reply
Pi
Infinity
User ID: 3.14159265
04-18-2012 05:19 AM

 



Post: #10
RE: Adama VS Kirk, whose the better leader?
No contest. Kirk!

Now.. as individuals? Shatner would lick ass to advance his career.
Quote this message in a reply
Nyhee
.
User ID: 89080
04-18-2012 05:27 AM

Posts: 3,579



Post: #11
RE: Adama VS Kirk, whose the better leader?
whoDunIt  Wrote:
There is no correct answer for this one, its all about preference. Of the two i prefer Adama, throw in a third choice and Sheridan has my vote. So now you all know what is wrong with me, i heart B5!

Sheridan was more realistic as a captain. I still prefer Kirk.

I love b 5 too. Heartflowers
Quote this message in a reply
WalkersEverywhere
Mortem comoedia ad ambulatories
User ID: 90821
04-18-2012 05:27 AM

Posts: 2,148



Post: #12
RE: Adama VS Kirk, whose the better leader?
Kirk, because:
1) Adama never f*cked a green girl.
2) Adama never did Lucy in the Sky With Diamonds.
3) Adama never did a cover version of any Black Sabbath song.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D-yy2URAYqU

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WM3J5B2rV...re=related
Quote this message in a reply
Rager
lop guest
User ID: 89580
04-18-2012 05:34 AM

 



Post: #13
RE: Adama VS Kirk, whose the better leader?
Who is Han solo for 500, Alex
Quote this message in a reply
WalkersEverywhere
Mortem comoedia ad ambulatories
User ID: 90821
04-18-2012 05:35 AM

Posts: 2,148



Post: #14
RE: Adama VS Kirk, whose the better leader?
Rager  Wrote:
Who is Han solo for 500, Alex

No rank, no military experience, no history of commanding multiple ships in combat.

Buy a vowel, padawan.
Quote this message in a reply
Zero Point
Well I thought it was funny.
User ID: 86957
04-18-2012 05:36 AM

Posts: 10,052



Post: #15
RE: Adama VS Kirk, whose the better leader?
Rager  Wrote:
Who is Han solo for 500, Alex

Not captain material I reckon.
Yoda however....

CENSORED (by popular demand).
Quote this message in a reply



Contact UsConspiracy Forum. No reg. required! Return to TopReturn to ContentRSS Syndication
HiFi High-End Audio PSUs for Laptops, Netbooks, Phono Preamps, USB Cables.

Valid XHTML 1.0 Transitional Valid CSS 2.1