|
Thread Rating:
- 5 Votes - 2.6 Average
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
|
Why is polygamy illegal?...
|
SeekerOfBrahma A3 aN T A oR E Sz User ID: 107651 07-19-2012 09:07 PM
Posts: 1,214
|
Why is polygamy illegal?...
is it because of jealousy from other males?.. just curious.
"We're all just prisoners in the e-camp!"
|
|
|
|
LoP Guest lop guest User ID: 54313 07-19-2012 09:08 PM
|
RE: Why is polygamy illegal?...
It should be legal.
|
|
|
|
~.~ Windy Soliloquy User ID: 109411 07-19-2012 09:10 PM
Posts: 10,041
|
RE: Why is polygamy illegal?...
because it fux up the IRS tax code
|
|
|
|
Kanigo2 lop guest User ID: 97971 07-19-2012 09:10 PM
|
RE: Why is polygamy illegal?...
I agree completely over regulated.
|
|
|
|
CourtDude Sporking ENFP Network Engineer User ID: 55747 07-19-2012 09:11 PM
Posts: 17,086
|
RE: Why is polygamy illegal?...
I'm curious too as polyamory works quite well as long as the three involved are mature and are not doing it for any exploitive reasons, are all treated fairly and no jealousy is involved.
In the end each other is all we have.
![[Image: AgilWOY.gif]](http://i.imgur.com/AgilWOY.gif)
320-250 | 52-229
|
|
|
|
Wolf Pup Can I hug your leg? User ID: 15878 07-19-2012 09:11 PM
Posts: 14,601
|
RE: Why is polygamy illegal?...
The answer to that question is that most Polygamist societies either are two class societies or they become two class societies eventually.
Generally speaking in a society there is roughly the same amount of women as their are men. So a society could maintain itself well enough, through monogamy. One wife one husband. It works out mathematically and everyone is happy.
The only thing is most societies did not do that. Most societies in history allowed more than one wife, though often there may have been a lot of rules about it.
Let us say that one third of the men marry all of the women. Then what do all the other men do?
You have two thirds of the men who are milling about. And then a war starts. Suppose that this war is against strict monogamists (a foreign nation). Who is going to fight harder, the monogamists or the polygamists?
Remember the two third men who are milling about? Do they look to you to be all motivated, to fight for the one third with the wives to you?
Once the fighting begins the monogamist are organized and are a band of the brothers and for most part everyone loves each other, where as the polygamists hate each, at least the two third hate the one third.
So the monogamists win in battle, they institute their laws and there language, and monogamy becomes the law for everyone, because eventually the monogamist take over everyone. The entire world becomes monogamist eventually.
This actually happened. First the monogamist Greeks, then the monogamist Romans, took over the world of Mesopotamia. Whenever the other countries fought against them the Greeks and then later the Romans, were far superior in actual combat. Band of brothers verses people that were jealous and envious and hated each other.
It really is as simple as that. Call it societal Darwinism. The Greco-Roman society is where our laws about marriage primarily come from. All the countries of Europe continued the Greco-Roman tradition of monogamy.
Europe in turn became the preeminent power in the world, thanks in no small part to the policy of monogamy, while at the same time as this was happening, the rest of the world was mostly polygamist.
Monogamy-ism helps social cohesion leading to greater cooperation among the soldier class, and also greater economic prosperity as well (the economic class is likewise more cooperative with each other).
In a nutshell that is why our laws and traditions are the way that they are.
"When life hands you a lime....."
|
|
|
|
SeekerOfBrahma A3 aN T A oR E Sz User ID: 107651 07-19-2012 09:13 PM
Posts: 1,214
|
RE: Why is polygamy illegal?...
I'd like to have more than one wife, it would keep things interesting.
"We're all just prisoners in the e-camp!"
|
|
|
|
Wolf Pup Can I hug your leg? User ID: 15878 07-19-2012 09:14 PM
Posts: 14,601
|
RE: Why is polygamy illegal?...
SeekerOfBrahma Wrote:I'd like to have more than one wife, it would keep things interesting.
Thats what "swinging" is for
"When life hands you a lime....."
|
|
|
|
SeekerOfBrahma A3 aN T A oR E Sz User ID: 107651 07-19-2012 09:18 PM
Posts: 1,214
|
RE: Why is polygamy illegal?...
Wolf Pup Wrote:The answer to that question is that most Polygamist societies either are two class societies or they become two class societies eventually.
Generally speaking in a society there is roughly the same amount of women as their are men. So a society could maintain itself well enough, through monogamy. One wife one husband. It works out mathematically and everyone is happy.
The only thing is most societies did not do that. Most societies in history allowed more than one wife, though often there may have been a lot of rules about it.
Let us say that one third of the men marry all of the women. Then what do all the other men do?
You have two thirds of the men who are milling about. And then a war starts. Suppose that this war is against strict monogamists (a foreign nation). Who is going to fight harder, the monogamists or the polygamists?
Remember the two third men who are milling about? Do they look to you to be all motivated, to fight for the one third with the wives to you?
Once the fighting begins the monogamist are organized and are a band of the brothers and for most part everyone loves each other, where as the polygamists hate each, at least the two third hate the one third.
So the monogamists win in battle, they institute their laws and there language, and monogamy becomes the law for everyone, because eventually the monogamist take over everyone. The entire world becomes monogamist eventually.
This actually happened. First the monogamist Greeks, then the monogamist Romans, took over the world of Mesopotamia. Whenever the other countries fought against them the Greeks and then later the Romans, were far superior in actual combat. Band of brothers verses people that were jealous and envious and hated each other.
It really is as simple as that. Call it societal Darwinism. The Greco-Roman society is where our laws about marriage primarily come from. All the countries of Europe continued the Greco-Roman tradition of monogamy.
Europe in turn became the preeminent power in the world, thanks in no small part to the policy of monogamy, while at the same time as this was happening, the rest of the world was mostly polygamist.
Monogamy-ism helps social cohesion leading to greater cooperation among the soldier class, and also greater economic prosperity as well (the economic class is likewise more cooperative with each other).
In a nutshell that is why our laws and traditions are the way that they are.
Why is always about war?..
Two or more wives per husband makes sense to me.. If there ever came a demand for more women, nature would provide them.. Nature has a good way of fixing any solution.
"We're all just prisoners in the e-camp!"
|
|
|
|
LoP Guest lop guest User ID: 101624 07-19-2012 09:19 PM
|
RE: Why is polygamy illegal?...
you can have as many baby-daddies as you please, just don't marry them.
|
|
|
|
LoP Guest lop guest User ID: 38278 07-19-2012 09:19 PM
|
RE: Why is polygamy illegal?...
You need to look up Reynolds v. United States circa 1895. The Supreme Court somehow ruled polygamy "unConstitutional." Once that happened, Utah was able to enter as a state.
|
|
|
|
OmegaEx-Moderator User ID: 9764 07-19-2012 09:19 PM
Posts: 21,040
|
RE: Why is polygamy illegal?...
Wolf Pup Wrote:The answer to that question is that most Polygamist societies either are two class societies or they become two class societies eventually.
Generally speaking in a society there is roughly the same amount of women as their are men. So a society could maintain itself well enough, through monogamy. One wife one husband. It works out mathematically and everyone is happy.
The only thing is most societies did not do that. Most societies in history allowed more than one wife, though often there may have been a lot of rules about it.
Let us say that one third of the men marry all of the women. Then what do all the other men do?
You have two thirds of the men who are milling about. And then a war starts. Suppose that this war is against strict monogamists (a foreign nation). Who is going to fight harder, the monogamists or the polygamists?
Remember the two third men who are milling about? Do they look to you to be all motivated, to fight for the one third with the wives to you?
Once the fighting begins the monogamist are organized and are a band of the brothers and for most part everyone loves each other, where as the polygamists hate each, at least the two third hate the one third.
So the monogamists win in battle, they institute their laws and there language, and monogamy becomes the law for everyone, because eventually the monogamist take over everyone. The entire world becomes monogamist eventually.
This actually happened. First the monogamist Greeks, then the monogamist Romans, took over the world of Mesopotamia. Whenever the other countries fought against them the Greeks and then later the Romans, were far superior in actual combat. Band of brothers verses people that were jealous and envious and hated each other.
It really is as simple as that. Call it societal Darwinism. The Greco-Roman society is where our laws about marriage primarily come from. All the countries of Europe continued the Greco-Roman tradition of monogamy.
Europe in turn became the preeminent power in the world, thanks in no small part to the policy of monogamy, while at the same time as this was happening, the rest of the world was mostly polygamist.
Monogamy-ism helps social cohesion leading to greater cooperation among the soldier class, and also greater economic prosperity as well (the economic class is likewise more cooperative with each other).
In a nutshell that is why our laws and traditions are the way that they are.
Good informative post!!!!
Man will never be free until the last politician is strangled with the entrails of the last banker - Diderot
|
|
|
|
Sunny Registered User User ID: 109353 07-19-2012 09:22 PM
Posts: 17,057
|
RE: Why is polygamy illegal?...
Gee one minute the men are complaining about how much they hate women and the next minute they are complaining because they can't get enough
|
|
|
|
SeekerOfBrahma A3 aN T A oR E Sz User ID: 107651 07-19-2012 09:24 PM
Posts: 1,214
|
RE: Why is polygamy illegal?...
Sunny Wrote:Gee one minute the men are complaining about how much they hate women and the next minute they are complaining because they can't get enough 
Its a love-hate thing, donchyaknow!
"We're all just prisoners in the e-camp!"
|
|
|
|
LoP Guest lop guest User ID: 75161 07-19-2012 09:24 PM
|
RE: Why is polygamy illegal?...
Was just listening to a historian talk about mormon women and polygamy. The rich mormon dudes had to distribute their assets around so they set up different homes/farms for all their wives who essentially became regional representatives and business managers for their husbands whom they meet in person infrequently. For these women polygamy was liberating relative to modern day poor-peoples polygamy with wives all packed into hovels with a hundred screaming brats.
|
|
|
|
|